Mark Guyula's election in NT 'wholly void', Electoral Commission tells court

Erstveröffentlicht: 
26.10.2016

The election of Independent MLA Yingiya Mark Guyula to the seat of Nhulunbuy was "wholly void" because he was a member of a local authority and paid in that role, court documents allege. The application filed by the Northern Territory Electoral Commission (NTEC) to the Court of Disputed Returns on October 21, 2016 sets out the detail of the Commission's case against Mr Guyula. The document states Mr Guyula was endorsed as a member of the Milingimbi Local Authority in 2014, and in 2015 the Authority's policy stated his appointment was for a period of four years.

 

"In his capacity as member of the Milingimbi Local Authority, the respondent attended its meetings on 15 October 2014, 19 December 2014, 16 December 2015 and 20 April 2016," the application stated.

"At those meetings, the respondent moved and/or seconded resolutions passed by the Milingimbi Local Authority."

Guyula 'paid allowance for attending meetings'

He also signed attendance sheets at each of those meetings and because he was a member of the Authority was entitled to an allowance, argued the NTEC.

"The respondent was paid by the East Arnhem Regional Council (EARC) the sums of $119, $119, $121.28 and $123.05 respectively for his attendance at the meetings."

Election of Guyula 'wholly void' says NTEC

The document states that prior to the writs being issued for the Northern Territory Election, Mr Guyula had not resigned from his appointment to the Authority, nor had his appointment been revoked by the EARC or expired.

"By virtue of the matters set out above, at the date of his nomination on 9 August 2016, the respondent was not qualified, within s21 (1)(a)(i) of the Northern Territory Self Government Act ... to be a candidate for election as a member of the Legislative Assembly because he held an appointment ...under a law of the Northern Territory and was entitled to remuneration or allowance," the document states.

"The applicant says that ....his return as the elected member of the Legislative Assembly for the Division of Nhlunubuy was wholly void and one of the other candidates referred to ...was entitled to be returned as elected."

The other candidates referred to in the Electoral Commission's application are Labor's Lynne Walker, Independent Jackson Anni and Country Liberals candidate Charlie Yunupingu.

The document points out that Ms Walker lost the seat to Mr Guyula by just eight votes on a two-candidate preferred basis.

The NTEC also outlines further grounds for the void result, including that the situation occurred without Mr Guyula's knowledge.

It argued, in either case, the poll result was likely to have been affected by the offence and the Court should decide Mr Guyula's election was "wholly void".

Zeige Kommentare: ausgeklappt | moderiert

Yingiya Mark Guyula maiden speech - NT parliament 2016

 

"We talk about closing the gap, but what gap are we talking about? The people of my electorate understand that this gap is the gap created when Yolŋu law is not properly acknowledged ...
 
That gap grows when Yolŋu children are forced into English-only schools, taught in a language they do not speak or hear in their community, like sending a Balanda child to a Yolŋu language-only school in Darwin.
 
The gap grows when Yolŋu children on homelands do not have equal access to education, qualified teachers attending every day and working with Yolŋu teachers and community to develop bilingual, bicultural curriculum, and for the children that is created on country and taught through Yolŋu language and culture, discipline, rehabilitation, educating young men and women towards being responsible, respectful parents and future leaders."

- Yingiya Mark Guyula, extract from maiden speech
Northern Territory Parliament 2016

 Independent Member of Nhulunbuy, Yingiya Mark Guyula, reading his maiden speech. Northern Territory Parliament 2016
(Image: Northern Territory Government via ABC News)
Northern Territory Government
The Thirteenth Assembly convened on 18 October 2016

Uncorrected Proof - (Closest translation/pronunciation of Yolŋu = Yolngu ) anscii 331
Yolŋu Languages (link is external)

 
Yingiya Mark Guyula (Nhulunbuy): (member spoke in language).
 
Translation: I am here from the Liya-dhalinymirr Djambarrpuyungu people of East Arnhem Land. I am Liya-dhalinymirr Djambarrpuyungu leader. I stand before this parliament here in good governance and respect.

Firstly I would like to acknowledge the land that I am standing on and the Larrakia Nation’s people and their ancestors past and present.

Let me begin by saying this is not something that I wanted to do. I did not want to become a politician but we Yolŋu have tried many ways of gaining recognition of Yolŋu law, and none have worked. I am here as an elected member but also as a diplomat from the Yolŋu (inaudible) bringing two parliaments together.

Our 1998 petition to Prime Minister John Howard read like this:

We request that the Australian government recognise

  1. the Dhulkmu-mulka Bathi (Title Deeds) which establish legal tenure for each of our traditional clan estates.

    Your Westminster system calls this native title.

  2. the jurisdiction of our Njarra’/Traditional Parliament in the same wasy as we recognise your Parliament and Westminster system of government

  3. both formally and legally recognise our Madayin system of law.

Yirrkala bark petitions 1963 were the first traditional documents prepared by First Nations people that were recognised by the Australian Parliament, and are thus the first documentary recognition of Indigenous people in Australian law.

Bark Petition Transcript 1963 pdf
Barunga Statement Transcript 1988 (link is external) pdf
Petition to Kevin Rudd Transcript 2008 (link is external) pdf

Similar requests for rights, land ownership and our way of life and self-governance were also made in the 1963 bark petitions, the 1998 Barunga statement and the 2008 petition to Kevin Rudd.

The leadership of Yolŋu people has always been very public about its request for treaty.

On numerous occasions this has been done by statements and petitions to the Australian government.

Perhaps our people’s most well-known declaration for treaty is the song by Yothu Yindi called
]">Treaty
.

Today I bring a letter stick to be tabled in the parliament; this is brought on behalf of the Yolŋu nation’s assembly.

The subsequent message is one of the Yolŋu nation’s, outlining the equal standing of the Njarra’ institution compared with Australian parliaments.

It is therefore a declaration of ongoing Yolŋu sovereignty while being a diplomatic gesture of intent and also the invitation to work towards a place of mutual acceptance between Yolŋu and Australian jurisdictions.

The declaration reads like this:

We declare that we have not been conquered. We declare that to this day we are a sovereign people. We declare that we will subject to our Madayin system of law constituted by the unseen creator of the universe and reveal to givers of law (inaudible), and we continue to steward this system through our lawful authroities and governments.
 
Our Madayin system of law is guarded by the Yothu Yindi separation of powers. Our Madayin system of law is a rule of law not a rule of man. Our Madayin system of law is the equal of any other system of law.
 
This is the most important thing I will say today; it is the reason I am here. It is the reason I stand before you.

To give you an even greater understanding of why I am here, standing before you, I will tell you about myself. I was born and raised in the bush. My father did not depend on others. He was given a job at the mission in Galiwinku, using the traditional knowledge. He used the skills he learnt from his father as a crocodile hunter, and this is what I learnt in my younger days until I was 10. I stayed away from school; I was camping, hunting, fishing and crocodile hunting with my father, and collecting bush foods with my mother.

At 10 years old I made the decision to go to school. I could not read or write and was laughed at. I was put in a class with younger children and quickly picked up skills. In one year I was put three levels beyond the class where I first started, where children laughed at me. Most of those kids finished school in primary school. I went to Dhupuma College and then Nhulunbuy High School.

I believe that my learning on country until the age of 10 gave me a strong Yolŋu identity, confidence and the ability to succeed later in life. Growing up on my mother’s parents’ country and my father’s country, I was nurtured—where my ancestors know me, where I feel strong standing on my country. Later I took up a job with Mission Aviation Fellowship in Nhulunbuy and Galiwinku as an aircraft maintenance engineer. They had a flying school in Ballarat, Victoria and I got my unrestricted private pilot’s licence to fly all over Australia.

I was learning about Balanda and getting a mixture of culture. I wanted to be on country for ceremonies and the traditional education, but I was also starting to enjoy a Balanda lifestyle. I was like a dog chasing two masters. I was picking up Balanda habits and then I had to drop that a catch up with my own culture. This is a hard time for many caught in two worlds. People say, ‘Come to the mainstream’ and on the other hand, ‘You need to be a leader and lean song lines and ceremonies which work towards those thing that are the law’.

I am now at the end of my full education with Yolŋu knowledge. There is still a lot to learn but I am a Djirrikaymirr. This is a leadership title of those who have a high level of learning. I have the authority to make constitutional decisions, create and produce a law. I have established this knowledge since my early 20s. Over the past 35 years I have dedicated myself to learning Yolŋu law which has provided everything we needed for thousands of years.

The issue of Yolŋu law is the main reason I have been selected by my electorate to represent them in the Northern Territory parliament. I am very proud of all grassroots support—Yolŋu and Balanda together— that circled around this campaign.

I return to my story of a dog and two masters. This is two masters going in different directions – one going this way and one going the other way. We talk about closing the gap, but what gap are we talking about? The people of my electorate understand that this gap is the gap created when Yolŋu law is not properly acknowledged. When the power of self-determination is increasingly being removed, that gap grows. When our people are starved out from the homelands and forced into major growth hub towns by the funding our infrastructure, health facilities, roads, homeland schools, etcetera.

Homeland centres are not hunting and fishing camps, but are residential clan states. They are centres of our society, foundational places of our social contract given importance by tradition and law at the foundation of our world. That gap grows when Yolŋu children are forced into English-only schools, taught in a language they do not speak or hear in their community, like sending a Balanda child to a Yolŋu language-only school in Darwin.

I understand this pressure. Even as an adult learning to fly I have failed written exams several times, but I was always above average in practical exams. I could navigate Victorian country almost instantly. We are capable of learning both ways but we need the strength of our first culture and language to obtain both.

The gap grows when Yolŋu children on homelands do not have equal access to education, qualified teachers attending every day and working with Yolŋu teachers and community to develop bilingual, bi-cultural curriculum, and for the children that is created on country and taught through Yolŋu language and culture, discipline, rehabilitation, educating young men and women towards being responsible, respectful parents and future leaders.

The gap grows when there is no training on country for young men and women who have finished their high school education to learn skills to gain employment that will allow them to be a part of their community. The gap growers outside the controls of economy ignore our corporate entities and limit our rates to negotiate terms of trade and benefit from our resources. The gap growers.

Family violence is happening now because young men and women have not been through a traditional process of learning to be responsible and preparing for respectful relationships. Our rights to maintain justice has been revoked by Balanda institutions. The only way to fix this is with policies of self-determination, self-management, self-governance and ultimately, a treaty.

This is not the first treaty for Yolŋu people. When the Macassans first landed on the north-east coast of Arnhem Land they recognised Yolŋu sovereignty and that a system of government already existed here. The Macassans negotiated for the right to fish certain waters and with our authority they were granted this right. In exchange for this fishery agreement, payments of clothes, tobacco, metal axes, knives and rice were made. Yolŋu of Arnhem Land also traded turtle shell, pearls and cypress vines, and some of our people were employed as trepangers.

The relationship between the Macassans and the Yolŋu tribes became so intertwined that the Macassan culture became included in some of our songlines and law. Songlines of tobacco and alcohol. Stories like the great whale hunter Wuymu, the Wurramala hunter, and culture like the use of flags.

We had two international treaties with the Macassans of Sulawesi. They engaged us with respect and honour, and they became our kin.

When I ask for a treaty, I am thinking of three requirements: the recognition of the Malayan system of law; the recognition of the East Arnhem Land body of government; and compensation for lost revenue from the blockage of historical international trade with the Macassans. This is called buyada, meaning restitution for wrongs done.

There is a going to be disagreement due to differences in cultures, but this will help us. It is like a footpath that has become overgrown or blocked. We need to trim the trees and the pathway again. This will hurt, but it will draw attention to areas that need to be closely examined and questioned.

Only through respectful dialogue and working together can we call Australia a nation based on the principles of democracy. A treaty will empower us, give us self-management, self-determination, bring pride and outcomes, allow us to make decisions for ourselves and put us in charge of our own destiny.

A treaty will allow us to move from the oppression of dependency and have a place where we might be human. I am here as a representative of the seat of Nhulunbuy, and I want to represent everyone; both Yolŋu and Balanda.

I am also here as a clan leader, and I am here as a representative of Yolŋu nations and its system of governance. I ask elected members to be part of the change that my electorate has voted for, in recognising Yolŋu law and walking with us in partnership towards a treaty.

I seek leave to table this letter stick from Yolŋu nations to the parliament.

Leave granted.